The 4 Eye Makeup Products Our Editors Swear By

If you're anything like us, we love experimenting with different eye makeup looks. But what we also love is finding out what eye shadows, mascaras and eyeliners are on high rotation in other people's beauty cupboards. Snoopy snoop! And mascara especially, because everyone prefers a different consistency and brush thickness. And what about eyeshadow? Are you a powder girl or a cream girl? Smokey eye or cats-eye? We asked the Sugar editors to reveal their most cherished eye product, so click through to find out.